My Inner Circle of Readers Rock!

With Free R.A.D.I.C.A.L. waiting impatiently at the starting gate for its publishing race to launch on January 14, 2027 – Amazon.com: Free RADICAL: 9781685138424: McCaffrey, Tom: Books – now available for pre-order

– all of my energy is focused on putting Spark of Faith to bed.

Toward that end, I am now working with David King at BRW on my seventh novel’s cover art, having already reviewed and tweaked the first presentation, and remain patiently waiting for the revision. Cover art is important because when you book appears among thousands of other on a web site or even in a bookstore, the potential reader’s eye must be captured by something aesthetically pleasing that also suggests the storyline in the book. You only get a nano-second to grab a literary shopper’s attention. You have to make it count.

While I await DK’s expectedly brilliant revisions, I am working with a wonderful group of people, my core inner circle of readers – Anna Hillman, Deborah Black, Renee Clarke, Eileen Cotto and Pete Sheridan – in finalizing the manuscript so there remains as few errors and typos in the published version as I can hope for. After all, perfect gets in the way of the good.

You see, with a mid-sized independent publisher, despite their best efforts, a lot of the finalization of a novel remains on the writer’s shoulders. So, despite my best efforts, there will always be those reviewers – Grammar Nazis – who may laude the work in general but will still be compelled to include an often-snide comment about some typo or error in punctuation, spelling or even an occasional homophone, because they want to show the other reviewers that they remain a cut above the average reader. Often, they will do it with a back-handed compliment, suggesting that some editor failed me as the writer for letting the error slip into the final product.

When you view these individual mistakes in the context of a work that is over a hundred-thousand words long, you realize that these comments border on petty.

But the editor is not to blame. The fault always lies with me. My buck stops here.

You see, in the raw, my writing style borders on the barbaric, just a level above cuneiforms. I remain the Leo Gorcey of modern-day writers. Leo Gorcey and misspoken words | The Pecan Park Eagle, (“Leo Gorcey as either Mugs or Slip or whomever else, was famous as the English language usage-butchering of words in strange context throughout this priceless series.”)

Given that understanding – as a man – I’m expected to know my limitations –

I have learned to compensate for my literary shortcomings by cultivating, over the past half-dozen years, this wonderful core group of readers that patiently sift through my daily output of writing and report back to me with whatever horrors they have encountered.

Now, as I have shared repeatedly, I channel write. I sit down before the blank screen each morning without any idea where a story is going. I just chase the characters across the page. The fugue state I enter remains until the literary elves type a chapter or two and then I wake up and email that collection of words to the inner circle who read it and let me know if a coherent story is developing.

This inner circle has been invaluable to me. They don’t sweat the small stuff and understand my writing style, and only on rare occasions question my story structure. They have come to understand that if they follow along patiently, I will tie up all loose ends. They trust my typing elves. So far, so good.

Now after the draft manuscript is complete, and the publisher has agreed to move forward into production, those very same readers again step up to the plate and go through the drafts – often a few times – looking for any errors they can find.

I cannot, have not, and will not read any of my completed novels. It’s too frightening. I recall the characters and the general story, but that’s about it.

What happens to my initial writing is that my circle and I go through a repeated winnowing process of them catching the errors and then I note those errors on a schedule. I literally search the document for the errors they identify and then note the chapter, page, paragraph and line where the error appears. I don’t read the story. I just can’t bring myself to do it.

It’s all part and parcel of my chronic case of Imposter Syndrome. If I read my own works, I’ll confirm in my mind that I’m a literary fraud. I just don’t have enough ego to withstand that truth.

Anyway, what I’ve found is that using many sets of discerning eyes catches many different problems. And an added plus is that women have an unerring eye for detail, and a great majority of my inner circle are the better sex. So, they catch those tiny things that many readers engrossed in a compelling story will read right over, but some may not, and the latter are the ones who enjoy showing that they caught me out in some acerbic review.

Pete Sheridan’s only roll is to ensure that the testosterone levels in my stories don’t drop below a respectable standard, and that any sexual activity is tastefully presented.

Well, over this past week, the members of my inner circle have all reread the publisher’s book version, pdf form of Spark of Faith. They have each separately sent me in their suggested corrections and proposed revisions. Quite honestly, it’s amazing how many errors still remained in this version, but I now understand that when you go from reading drafts in Word documents to pdf documents, your eyes pick up mistakes that they once read over.

And the strangest thing is that no matter how thorough and detailed each member’s comments to me are, there is always something spotted that is unique to the person who is doing the reading.

It works like a Venn diagram. There are core mistakes that everyone – but me – catches, and which would embarrass the shit out of me had they made it to the final printing, and then unique floaters that each one catches that the others may have missed. Most readers may read right past those errors but then the Grammar Nazi would certainly appear and highlight that one mistake, just because they can.

So here I am throughout this past week collecting each of these wonderful reader’s comments and catches and incorporating them onto the hopefully final schedule that will undoubtedly shock the production team at BRW when they realize that the schedule has reached more than 16 pages.

I cannot say enough good things about the willingness of my inner circle of readers to engage in this repeated tedious process novel after novel. I am forever in their debt – which I try to repay by creating wonderful characters in the stories that bear their names.

When it’s all said and done and the book is finally launched, I have confidence that – while it may not be perfect – the final product will be good enough to take the readers on a magical journey that makes each one feel like they themselves are characters in the story. And as a writer, that is all I can hope for.

Well, that’s it for today’s publishing lesson.

You fine, five readers have made it to another Thursday, which means that you give those work projects a final push and get them finalized, wrapped and topped with a pretty bow. Then keep them safe until tomorrow when you deliver them to whomever signs your paycheck.

So, finish that last cuppa and launch.

And no matter what else we get up to, let us make today a great one.

5 Responses

  1. Vince Lombardi has been quoted as saying, “Perfection is not attainable, but if we chase perfection we can catch excellence.”
    Leo Tolstoy said, “If you look for perfection, you’ll never be content.”
    My dad said, “If we were perfect, we could run for God.”

    What is most important, is the story. It’s the backbone that captures your imagination and makes you keep turning the pages.

    Free R.A.D.I.C.A.L and Spark of Faith do just that.
    I’m honored to have been a part of both books.

    1. Yes, SOF will probably be available for pre-sale in the beginning of January before FR actually drops. If I can get the cover finalized and the final edits in before the end of November, SOF may arrive for pre-sale earlier.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share this Post:  

Sign up for blog updates!
Join my email list to receive updates and information.